9856 Tollgate Lane Montgomery, OH 45242

4
Bed
4/1
Bath
4,371
Sq. Ft
0.39
Acres
$1,400,000
MLS# 1885734
4 BR
4/1 BA
4,371 Sq. Ft
0.39 AC
1/51
  • New Listing
2/51
3/51

On Market 07/09/2026

More About 9856 Tollgate Lane

This Sycamore School District home offers about 4,400 sqft on a premier lot. Its bright, open floor plan features a gourmet kitchen with a large island, quartz counters, a walk-in pantry, and ample cabinetry. The great room with gas fireplace opens to a screened porch and patio for seamless indoor-outdoor living. The main-level primary suite includes a tray ceiling, spa-like bath, and walk-in closet. A private study with French doors is perfect for remote work. Upstairs are three bedroomstwo share a Jack-and-Jill bath, and one has an en-suite. The finished lower level offers a fifth bedroom or fitness space, full bath, and rec room. Upgrades include fresh paint, new carpet, AC (2023), and an oversized 3-car garage. Built in 2018, this home blends timeless design and modern amenities. Schedule your private tour today!

Seller open to concessions based on the terms of the offer!

Directions to this Listing

: Montgomery Rd to Mitchell Farm Ln to Left on Tollgate Ln

Information Refreshed: 7/09/2026 12:04 AM

Headshot of Rob & Beth Mahoney

Rob & Beth Mahoney

Mahoney Group

513-313-4245
CallText
Contact Rob to learn more or 

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Property Details

  • MLS#:

    1885734

  • Type:

    Single Family

  • Sq. Ft:

    4,371

  • County:

    Hamilton

  • Age:

    8

  • Appliances:

    Oven/Range, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Microwave, Garbage Disposal, Gas Cooktop

  • Architecture:

    Traditional

  • Basement:

    Finished, WW Carpet

  • Basement Type:

    Full

  • Construction:

    Brick, Fiber Cement

  • Cooling:

    Central Air

  • Fireplace:

    Gas

  • Flex Room:

    Bonus Room, Game Room, Screened Porch

  • Garage:

    Garage Attached, Front, Oversized

  • Garage Spaces:

    3

  • Gas:

    Natural

  • Great Room:

    Fireplace, Wood Floor

  • Heating:

    Gas, Forced Air

  • Inside Features:

    Multi Panel Doors, French Doors, 9Ft + Ceiling

  • Kitchen:

    Pantry, Wood Cabinets, Wood Floor, Planning Desk, Eat-In, Gourmet, Island, Quartz Counters

  • Mechanical Systems:

    Sump Pump w/Backup

  • Misc:

    Ceiling Fan, Recessed Lights, 220 Volt

  • Parking:

    On Street, Driveway

  • Primary Bedroom:

    Wall-to-Wall Carpet, Bath Adjoins, Walk-in Closet

  • S/A Taxes:

    10919

  • School District:

    Sycamore Community City

  • Sewer:

    Public Sewer

  • Water:

    Public

Rooms

  • Bath 1:

    F (Level: 1)

  • Bath 2:

    P (Level: 1)

  • Bath 3:

    F (Level: 2)

  • Bath 4:

    F (Level: 2)

  • Bedroom 1:

    20x19 (Level: 1)

  • Bedroom 2:

    16x13 (Level: 2)

  • Bedroom 3:

    14x13 (Level: 2)

  • Bedroom 4:

    14x11 (Level: 2)

  • Breakfast Room:

    16x11 (Level: 1)

  • Dining Room:

    15x14 (Level: 1)

  • Entry:

    10x6 (Level: 1)

  • Family Room:

    18x16 (Level: Lower)

  • Great Room:

    23x21 (Level: 1)

  • Kitchen:

    16x15 (Level: 1)

  • Laundry Room:

    8x7 (Level: 1)

  • Recreation Room:

    36x18 (Level: Lower)

  • Study:

    12x11 (Level: 1)
This listing courtesy of Rob Mahoney (513) 313-4245, Beth Mahoney (513) 477-6520, Montgomery Office (513) 793-2700

Explore Montgomery & Surrounding Area

Montgomery

Montgomery

The spirit of Montgomery is anything but old-fashioned. Montgomery has enjoyed being consistently rated as one of the top communities for the Cincinnati area. Single-family homes, townhouses, condos and apartments of almost every design are found th...

View Community
Kenwood OH

Kenwood

The Kenwood area is a suburban community of attractive houses on neatly landscaped lots. The many mature trees that have been preserved add to the charm of this neighborhood. Homes vary in status and style, but throughout, there are fine examples of arc...

View Community
Indian Hill OH 4

Indian Hill

The village is governed by an elected council and professional manager. Indian Hill has its own water supply, and exceptional police and fire protection. Its recreational facilities are varied and well patronized. The community has its own service depar...

View Community
Blue Ash

Blue Ash

The availability of many contemporary new homes, combined with an ever-present possibility of rising values, makes it an ideal place to invest. One finds homes of all ages, styles and price ranges from modest-priced homes to luxury condos and houses. Ma...

View Community
Loveland OH

Loveland

The only city in Ohio situated in three counties, Warren, Hamilton and Clermont, Loveland is located on the scenic Little Miami River, 16 miles north of Cincinnati. Loveland residents and businesses enjoy a quiet country setting, while still having easy...

View Community
Miami Township OH (2)

Miami Township (East)

Like many other townships surrounding the I-275 outer beltway surrounding Cincinnati, Clermont County’s Miami Township began changing from rural countryside as late as 1960, to today’s township exploding with growth. The growth is carefully planned and ...

View Community
Symmes Twp OH

Symmes Township

It's quite a change since the first pioneers came to this area in the 1790s, but a link remains between the first settlers and today's suburban dweller – an appreciation for open spaces, privacy and a less hectic life. Symmes Township bears the name of ...

View Community
Madiera_OH2

Madeira

Madeira has merited quite a few “Best Ofs” throughout the years from Business Week, Cincy Magazine and US News and World Report. The community has many spirited citizens who work diligently to preserve a friendly neighborhood setting. One of the prime a...

View Community
OH•45242•Hamilton County•Montgomery•9856 Tollgate Lane
Headshot of Rob & Beth Mahoney

Rob & Beth Mahoney

Mahoney Group

513-313-4245
CallText
Contact Rob to learn more or 

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Monthly Cost

Mortgage Calculator

Enter your details for an estimated monthly payment. See how much house you can afford

%
LEGAL DISCLAIMERS▼

Your estimated payment

$7,028
per month
PRINCIPAL & INTEREST
$7,028
CHAT WITH A LOAN OFFICER

Sell with Sibcy Cline

Enter your address for a free market report on your home. Explore your home value estimate, buyer heatmap, supply-side trends, and more.

Must reads

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity programs of the MLS of Greater Cincinnati, Inc. Those listings held by brokerage firms other than Sibcy Cline, Inc. are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and house icon. The properties displayed may not be all of the properties available through Broker Reciprocity. Copyright© 2026 Multiple Listing Services of Greater Cincinnati / All Information is believed accurate, but is NOT guaranteed.